CURRENT NEWS AND NEWSLETTERS ARCHIVE

RWC: Poor Refereeing is Killing the Game

Card image cap

In a World Cup – any World Cup – fans could be forgiven for expecting to see the very best of the best on show. The best players, the best coaches and, dare we say it, the best officials. But World Rugby appears to have settled for following the lyrics of an old Meatloaf track: Two our of three ain’t bad.

Hardly a day has gone by in Rugby World Cup 2019 that hasn’t seen at least one new refereeing controversy. Without detailing every single error in every game [We'd need a book for that – Ed], we have extracted a few “highlights” that had us either laughing out loud or shaking our heads in exasperation.

Consider the Wales vs Fiji match earlier this week. The clown with the whistle was Jérôme Garcès and, in this game, he consistently ignored Welsh players going off their feet in mauls while penalising Fijians for the exact same thing.

It’s the second time Fiji has been the victim of piss-poor refereeing at this World Cup. The first was thanks to the incompetent Ben O’Keeffe when the islanders played Australia in their opening fixture. Even more ironic, Jonathan Kaplan, one of the worst South Africa ever produced, agrees, apparently.The reality is that, if World Rugby really wants to grow the game globally, something must be done about the abysmally poor of refereeing – at all levels. If that means simplifying the laws still more; empowering TMOs to overturn poor decisions; or to independently grade referee performances in every match, so be it. There’s a great piece this week by Andy Bull in The Guardian on this very subject.



View newsletters in pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 42 - 2019-11-08.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 41 - 2019-11-01.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 40 - 2019-10-25.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 39 - 2019-10-18.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 38 - 2019-10-11.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 37 - 2019-10-04.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 36 - 2019-09-27.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 35 - 2019-09-20.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 34 - 2019-09-13.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 33 - 2019-09-06.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 32 - 2019-08-29.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 31 - 2019-08-22.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 30 - 2019-08-15.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 29 - 2019-08-08.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 28 - 2019-08-01.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 27 - 2019-07-25.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 26 - 2019-07-18.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 25 - 2019-07-11.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 24 - 2019-07-04.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 23 - 2019-06-27.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 22 - 2019-06-20.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 21 - 2019-06-13.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 20 - 2019-06-06.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 19 - 2019-05-30.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 18 - 2019-05-23.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 17 - 2019-05-16.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 16 - 2019-05-09.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 15 - 2019-05-02.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 14 - 2019-04-25.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 13 - 2019-04-18.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 12 - 2019-04-11.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 11 - 2019-04-04.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 10 - 2019-03-28.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 09 - 2019-03-21.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 08 - 2019-03-14.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 07 - 2019-03-07.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 06 - 2019-02-28.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 05 - 2019-02-21.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 04 - 2019-02-14.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 03 - 2019-02-07.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 02 - 2019-01-31.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 19, Iss 01 - 2019-01-24.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 18 - 2018-12-06.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 17 - 2018-11-29.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 16 - 2018-11-22.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 15 - 2018-11-15.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 14 - 2018-11-08.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 13 - 2018-11-01.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 12 - 2018-10-25.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 11 - 2018-10-18.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 10 - 2018-10-11.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 09 - 2018-10-04.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 08 - 2018-09-27.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 07 - 2018-09-20.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 06 - 2018-09-13.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 05 - 2018-09-05.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 04 - 2018-08-30.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 03 - 2018-08-22.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 02 - 2018-08-15.pdf
  • Rugby ZA Vol 01, Iss 01 - 2018-08-08.pdf
  • Ads